Kirishitan Sites in Tokyo
First published October 2012
Last modified June 2017
What is a Kirishitan?
Kirishitan (sometimes spelled Kirish'tan) is simply the old Japanese word for Christian.
As for pronunciation, kee-leesh-tan is close enough.
Today Japanese Christians are called Kurisuchan (koo-lees-chan).
The name Kirishitan is usually written in either katakana or hiragana characters, but it originally appeared in the form of kanji characters.
These kanji were later altered when it was found that the fifth Tokugawa Shogun, Tsunayoshi (1646 -1709) also had one of the kanji in his name (KI is also pronounced YOSHI).
So the pair of kanji for KIRI was changed to a single kanji with a different meaning. This kanji was the character for cutting, and when combined with second kanji which can mean branch, it conjures up the image of cutting off branches.
This was intended as a cruel insult to Kirishitans who were often punished by severing body parts including limbs, and were often executed by beheading.
Kirishitans in Tokyo
The largest Kirishitan populations were in Kyushu, and today the great majority of Kirishitan sites are located down there including the famous spot where the twenty-six martyrs were crucified in Nagasaki. By comparison Tokyo (called Edo in those days) had a much smaller Kirishitan presence, and has only a few Kirishitan sites.
I have been able to track down lots of information from various sources including old out of print library books in Tokyo. Some of these books had horizontal lines of Japanese text running from right to left which indicates they were published before World War II. Tokyo has changed drastically since then, which makes it very difficult to track down these sites based on the descriptions. Even old photos are no longer helpful as buildings and entire neighborhoods have been demolished and replaced by newer office buildings and shopping complexes in ever-changing Tokyo.
One of those old books stated that there are only five Kirishitan sites in Tokyo. However, after studying many other sources, I managed to identify eight sites. Four of those have no markers to identify the precise location. I describe all eight sites in this article.
I have read that there are more unmarked sites connected to Kirishitan stories around Tokyo, and this article continues to grow as new archaeological discoveries appear in the news.
Let me start from the beginning and in chronological order weave some of the stories of the Kirishitans into the descriptions of the sites which I have found.
The first missionaries
Francis Xavier was the first Christian missionary to arrive in Japan.
Perhaps I should qualify that statement because there are some researchers in Japan who will object if I don't mention that apparently there is evidence that Christianity had reached Japan many centuries earlier.
I have no reason to doubt this, but even if it is true, any Christian community that might have existed during that earlier era had long vanished before Xavier's arrival.
Francis Xavier arrived in Kagoshima on the southern island of Kyushu on August 15, 1549. He was accompanied by two missionaries and a Japanese man named Yajiro (or Anjiro) who met Xavier earlier and had told him about this amazing country in the Far East called Japan.
Xavier did not come as far north as Tokyo which was called Edo in those days.
He was only in Japan for a little over two years and spent his entire time in the southern part of Japan with only one visit to Kyoto the old capital of Japan in hopes of meeting and converting the emperor.
That meeting never took place, and Xavier returned south to focus his efforts on the local rulers (daimyo).
This new strategy proved very successful. During his short time in Japan, Xavier baptized some 760 Japanese including many influential military rulers.
Francis Xavier had great hope for this nation. He wrote:
Japan is the only country yet discovered in these regions where there is hope of Christianity permanently taking root.
Even with all their trials, it was apparently an exciting time for Francis Xavier and his fellow missionaries as the Japanese eagerly embraced the gospel in ever increasing numbers.
According to reports and an investigation by Church authorities, Xavier's ministry was even accompanied by extraordinary miracles including raising the dead. Although there were many eye-witness testimonies by Xavier's co-workers and converts, he himself was silent on the matter.
But dark clouds were on the horizon. Francis Xavier was in charge of all the missionary work in the Far East, and his other duties forced him to leave Japan for a while -- with every intention of returning later with more missionaries.
He left Oita (called Funai at the time) at the end of 1551, and a year later died of a fever on Shangchuan island off the coast of China.
His two companions, Fr. Cosme De Torres and Brother Juan Fernandez stayed on in Japan and sacrificially gave their lives to the work for the next sixteen years, overseeing the Church in Japan which spread as more missionaries arrived, some sent by Xavier himself before he died.
His successor in charge of all the missions, Fr. Alexander Valignano wrote:
Of all the nations that I have ever visited, Japan is the most appropriate nation to receive God's salvation.
Christianity reaches Edo
Then in 1597 Christianity was forbidden by Hideyoshi Toyotomi who was the military ruler of Japan after Nobunaga's death. The priests were scattered and the Church continued to preach the gospel but not openly as before. Persecution and martyrdom became a reality and yet the Church continued to spread.
The Church eventually reached Edo (Tokyo) where Tokugawa Ieyasu had based his operations and built his impressive castle which would become the military capital of Japan for over two and a half centuries during the Edo era.
Although Christianity had been officially outlawed by Hideyoshi Toyotomi, Tokugawa Ieyasu did not enforce this ban at first. He even gave permission to a Spanish Franciscan missionary from Kyoto, Fr. Geronimo de Jesus Castro, to begin evangelistic work in Edo.
Although the missionary work in southern and central Japan had been initially done by Jesuit priests, in Tokyo and northern Japan the work was begun by Francisan and Dominican missionaries.
The first Church in Edo
In 1599 Fr. Geronimo built a chapel in the area of Hatchobori and Nihonbashi with the full permission of Tokugawa Ieyasu. This chapel was the first Christian church in Edo and was called ROZARIO NO GENKOU SEI MARIA SEIDO (Church of Queen Holy Mary of the Rosary).
In 1601 Fr. Geronimo had an audience with Ieyasu. This was after the decisive battle of Sekigahara of 1600 which paved the way for Ieyasu to become shogun (military commander-in-chief of Japan) in 1603. He presented the soon-to-be shogun many gifts (including tobacco seeds which later had a different sort of impact on Japan's culture) and apparently won his favor.
Ieyasu then sent him to the Philippines as his ambassador. Fr. Geronimo returned to Japan and died in Kyoto in 1601.
The church building became the base for further evangelism in Edo and the surrounding areas under the leadership of Spanish Franciscan, Fr. Luis Sotelo who carried on the work after Fr. Geronimo's death. The number of Kirishitans in Edo reached around 3,000.
Then the Tokugawa Shoguns turned against Christianity and worked hard to eradicate it. In 1612 Christianity was banned from Edo.
In 1613 Tokugawa Hidetada, son of Ieyasu, destroyed the chapel -- 14 years after it had been constructed.
Today the exact location of that chapel is unknown.
However, in the year 2000 an old burial site was discovered just northeast of Tokyo station where the GranTokyo North Tower and the Marunouchi Trust Towers now stand, and it contained Kirishitan artifacts.
This graveyard was from the period between 1580 and 1600, and had at least one European style wood coffin with the body laid out horizontally, which was very unusual in Edo where the practice of cremation -- associated with Buddhism at the time -- was prevalent. Bodies were placed in a wooden container resembling a barrel or tub, in an upright sitting position with the legs drawn up and the knees touching the chest. The skeletal remains had Asian features which indicates it was not a European missionary. There was also a Christian medal and some rosary beads in the coffin.
Today there is not so much as a plaque to indicate the exact location of this discovery. But the medal and rosary beads plus a photo of the coffin are in a permanent exhibition at the Hibiya Library in Hibiya Park not far from the burial site (and one would hope that somebody gave the remains a decent Christian burial in a new location).
I visited the library and took photos of the display.
The description says that the medal has an image which could be either Christ or Mary along with the inscription "Immaculate Holy Mother" (which makes it clear that this is an image of Mary!). Both the medal and beads are very old and the lighting was not so bright, so it was impossible to make out any details in the display case, or take a decent photo with my simple camera.
So here are photos I found on the internet which show more details.
It was in the general Nihonbashi/Hatchobori area where the chapel was said to have been constructed, and one could imagine that Christians would want to be buried near the church building as was the custom in Europe.
At the very least, ROZARIO NO GENKOU SEI MARIA SEIDO wasn't far away and we can assume that the Kirishitan who was buried here was associated with it since there was no other church in Edo.
After Tokugawa Hidetada destroyed this chapel, he refused to give permission to build a new one, but Fr. Sotelo went ahead and built a new chapel anyway -- just a simple hut -- to serve as their headquarters about two kilometers away to the north in the Asakusa-Torigoe area, on the grounds of a leper hospital which was run by Kirishitans.
The new church was completed on May 12, 1613 and this lead to the arrest of twenty seven Kirishitans involved who were thrown into Kodenmacho prison and then executed at the Asakusa-Torigoe execution grounds in three groups on August 16, 17, and September 19 of that year. Fr. Sotelo was also arrested and put into the same prison but was later released to Date Masamune, a daimyo who interceded on his behalf. Masamune took the priest up north to Sendai.
On January 27, 1614 the famous decree was issued banning Christianty from all of Japan, and the executions of Kirishitans increased.
Fr. Sotelo left Japan in 1618, but returned in 1622. This time he was imprisoned for two years and then burned at the stake in 1624.
Asakusa-Torigoe execution grounds
Among the buildings which now occupy this area is a Catholic church called Asakusa Catholic Church. It has a memorial dedicated to the Kirishitan martyrs who were executed at the Asakusa-Torigoe execution grounds which, according to one book I have read, was just to the northeast of this church, in the same neighborhood.
I went to visit this church on a national holiday and was dismayed to find that the gates were locked. The church is located on a small plot of land surrounded on all sides by sidewalks so I walked around to the back and discovered the memorial there, always open to the public.
The names of the twenty-seven martyrs mentioned above are recorded on this memorial. It says that in that area on August 16, 1613, among the group of prisoners taken from Kodenmacho prison to be beheaded were eight Kirishitan, and on the next day (August 17) fourteen more Kirishitans were executed, and on September 19 five more Kirishitan were executed. It mentions that one of these had just been baptized in the prison on September 19, and also lists the name of one more Kirishitan who had died in the prison, for a total of twenty-eight names.
Next to the plaque is a rounded stone that has an engraved cross and the following inscription in Japanese: Asakusa-Torigoe Kirishitan Martyrs Memorial.
Edo's notorious prison for nearly three centuries from 1596 till 1875 was located in Kodenmacho in central Edo near Nihonbashi. The grounds were surrounded on all four sides by a moat filled with water. The spot where it stood is now Jisshi Park. It's a small clearing with stones, gravel and trees typical of Tokyo inner city parks, and has a small pond. It's hidden by surrounding buildings but easy to find because it is right at Kodenmacho station. An elevator from the subway station actually opens at the park entrance where there is a large sign telling the story of this prison.
The prison was more of a stable than a prison and was itself often the cause of death for prisoners. It was so dark you could see nothing. Everyone sat on the floor, but there was no room to stretch your legs and you could only get to sleep by leaning on the person next to you. Most of the inmates were stripped down to a loincloth. There was no toilet, which meant the filth and stench would be overwhelming. When there was any kind of disturbance, the guards would pour buckets of human waste on everyone. And when prisoners died, their bodies were left in their position between fellow prisoners to rot for sometimes over a week.
Most of what we know about this prison comes from the writing of Diego de San Francisco who actually spent a year and a half inside and lived to tell the story.
Diego de San Francisco
Franciscan Priest Diego de San Francisco arrived in Japan in 1612 and was active in Evangelism in Kyoto. After the ban on Christianity in 1614 he continued his work secretly for another year until he was arrested in 1615 and thrown into the notorious Kodenmacho prison for a year and a half. Then he was released from prison and deported to Mexico in 1616.
In 1618 he managed to enter Japan again and returned to Edo, this time disguised as a Japanese. He stayed for a time at the hospital for lepers near Asakusa where he ministered to the patients.
Then Fr. Diego left the leper facility and lived in hiding on the property of Kato Samanosuke Yoshiaki, which was reportedly as large as a town with several buildings, and surrounded by a moat.
He stayed at the house of Kato's chief retainer, which became the base of his secret evangelistic activities.
However, someone informed Kato. Kato investigated the affair and had his chief retainer beheaded.
When he learned that Diego had previously stayed at the leper facility, Kato had all fifty resident patients arrested, and beheaded their leader.
The compound of Kato Samanosuke Yoshiaki is now an office block (or blocks) near Uchisaiwai-Cho station, across the large street from the Hibiya Kokusai building.
An old history book I found in a library identified the buildings which stood on the exact site. I went to the area more than once trying to find those buildings and even asked the police officers at the local Koban (Police box) if they had any idea where the buildings might be. They had no idea. It turned out that those buildings have been torn down a long time ago and replaced by the one shown in the photo, called the Saiwai Building.
If the former residence was really as big as a town, then the surrounding buildings also stand on the old property.
I walked around and searched for some kind of marker or sign but there was none. The story is preserved only in old books.
Asakusa-yama execution grounds
In 1620 the execution grounds for Edo were moved from Asakusa-Torigoe to an area about two kilometers north called Asakusa-yama still near the Sumida River.
According to a book I have, the grounds were located somewhere in the vicinity of the intersection of Edo Dori (Avenue) and Kototoi Dori (Avenue) near the river.
I went there and walked around but could not find a trace of the execution grounds anywhere near this bustling intersection.
Today the area is dominated by the Tokyo Sky Tree across the Sumida River, which is the tallest tower in the world (as of this writing).
Since I could not find any plaque or memorial, I snapped a photo of the intersection with Tokyo Sky Tree in the background. About a week later I returned to the area and searched more carefully down by the river and along the side streets, but turned up nothing. Both times I asked the police officers who were stationed at the Koban at that intersection, but they had no idea where it had been located. My inquiries have had many police officers scratching their heads with puzzled looks.
It seems incredible that there would be no indication of such a significant site in this area. I've gone back many times and have covered every street in the entire neighborhood, and haven't found any clues.
My personal speculation is that the execution grounds are now a park called Hanakawado (or Hanagawado ) which is near this intersection just to the south west, and just a few blocks to the east of the Sensoji Temple grounds in Asakusa.
The park has a small pond called Ubagaike which used to be much larger and was connected to the Sumida River nearby. I would imagine that access to flowing water would be a necessity since execution was a messy business.
A sign at the park tells a different tale of murders in a house nearby, and a suicide at this pond -- but says nothing about criminal executions. If you can't read the sign, click on it to see a larger one.
The Japanese sign adds that the woman killed and robbed 999 men this way before killing herself in this pond, and that the events supposedly took place in the 6th century.
Perhaps eleven-hundred years later the Tokugawa government saw it as a fitting place for executions since there was not much else they build on a spot with such a reputation; nobody would want to build houses or businesses there as the Japanese tend to avoid all association with death!
Just like the former site of Kodenmacho prison (above) where so many died, practically the only thing they could build on a site like this now is a public park. Here's a photo of the pond in the park.
I have visited this park several times, and it did have a spooky feeling, but that's not surprising considering my suspicions. One can imagine condemned criminals being lead down that walkway to the middle of the pond where the executioner was waiting.
As for other likely candidates for the Asakusa-Yama execution grounds, this is the only park in the vicinity -- if you don't count the long park that runs along the Sumida River which was (and is) a popular spot for strolling and cherry blossom viewing and not a very wise choice for an execution spot.
In addition to countless criminals, at least 231 Kirishitans were executed at the Asakusa-Yama execution grounds according to my source which also records how they were killed.
The first executions were carried out by beheading as was the custom at the earlier execution grounds, but subsequent killings are described in my book with a Japanese term which can be translated as hanging upside down.
The Kirishitans were publicly executed in order to discourage the faith of other believers and prevent more people from joining their ranks, but the joy and boldness of many Kirishitans as they faced death had the opposite effect, and onlookers marveled at their inner strength which could only be attributed to divine power.
The Grand Inquisitor for the Tokugawa government was Inoue Masashige, whose title was Chikugo-no-kami (lord of Chikugo, a city in Kyushu). At least two sources said that Inoue was appointed to this post because he was in a homosexual relationship with Tokugawa Iemitsu who was the grandson of Tokugawa Ieyasu.
According to one source, Inoue was also an ex-Kirishitan himself, and now it was his job to eradicate Christianity from Japan. He invented a cruel form of torture which was aimed at getting Kirishitans to renounce their faith.
The victim was tied up and suspended upside down from the feet, with his head in a pit which was often filled with human waste. Some might still die in a few hours while others might remain that way for a few days -- unless they apostatized.
To relieve the blood pressure on the head and prolong the agony, victims would be bound up with ropes very tightly and sometimes a gash was cut in the forehead to allow the blood to escape.
This new cruel punishment was called "the pit" and was described as the worse form of torture imaginable.
Mass execution at Fuda No Tsuji in 1623
The next site is the location of the most famous Kirishitan martydom incident in Edo. It marked the beginning of the intense persecutions of the Church in Edo.
In 1623, nineteen year old Tokugawa Iemitsu, grandson of Ieyasu, had just become the new Shogun in place of his father Hidetada. He immediately set out to destroy the Church.
On December 4 of the same year, fifty Kirishitans were ordered to be executed. These included Jesuit Father Jerome de Angelis, Franciscan Father Francis Galvez, Japanese Jesuit Brother Simon Enpo, and Japanese layman John Hara Mondo
During their time in the prison, the missionaries were held in separate parts of the prison, and each continued to boldly preach the gospel to their fellow prisoners day and night, with the result that many of the condemned criminals believed and converted to the Christian faith, and some were baptized right there in the prison (sprinkled with what scant drinking water was available).
After waiting in this prison for a month, fifty of the Kirishitan prisoners were led out to execution on December 4. This time, rather than using the execution grounds a little to the north in Asakusa (mentioned above), it was decided to make them an example in a more public place where a larger crowd could witness the event, including the many daimyo (feudal lords) visiting Edo at the time from all over Japan who might have been inclined to be more tolerant of Kirishitans in their own domains.
The execution spot was to be outside the city gates to the south on a wooded hill called Fuda No Tsuji which faced the sea. It was on the Tokaido, which was the main highway running through Japan and which was always filled with travelers.
The Kirishitan prisoners were made to parade from Kodenmacho prison through the streets of Edo all the way to the city limits and on to the top of the hill. Judging by my map of Tokyo, they must have walked about seven kilometers (over four miles).
The prisoners were divided into three groups. The two priests plus Hara Mondo were made to ride on horseback. Fr. Jerome de Angelis rode at the front of the first group, Fr. Francis Galvez rode at the front of the second group, and Hara Mondo rode at the front of the last group. The tendons of Hara Mondo's hands and feet had been severed in a previous arrest, and he could not walk. He could not even stay balanced on a horse by himself, so he was secured to the horse's back by ropes. His nose had also been cut off and a cross branded on his forehead.
The execution had been announced in advance so that there was a large crowd waiting around this hill and a neighboring hill as well.
The method of execution this time would be burning at the stake rather than beheading or hanging in the pit. Fifty living human beings screaming as they were engulfed in flames on this hill by the Tokaido would surely make a lasting impression on the public.
As it turned out, the impression made was not what they had planned on.
Much of the description that follows is derived from a written eyewitness account of the event.
When they reached the site, they saw fifty stakes prepared, with three of them set apart in the area closest to the city. Each prisoner was tied to a stake except for the three on horseback who were made to stay on their horses for the time being so they could witness the execution of the others. From their positions above the crowds the missionaries continued to preach boldly to all who could hear.
The Jesuit Brother Simon Enpo who was to be burned in the first group with the others, had preached to the onlookers during the march through Edo and now continued to preach boldly as he was being tied to the stake, encouraging the crowds to believe in Christ.
As the flames rose, none of the martyrs showed any sign of pain. Instead they all showed great courage and even joy as they offered up praise to God, to the amazement of the great crowd who recognized that this could not be possible by human efforts alone.
As a matter of fact, a man and a woman rushed out of the crowd and shouted loudly to the guards that they, too, were Kirishitans and deserved to be executed. They were however, arrested and imprisoned instead. They would be executed later -- on this same spot.
After the first group of believers had all perished and the fires had died out, the three leaders were taken off their horses and tied to the stakes. They continued to encourage each other and proclaim their faith in Christ. Fr. Jerome prayed for the city and then faced the flames directly and spoke to the crowds who were watching him closely. Finally he fell to his knees and died.
John Hara Mondo encircled the flames with his arms as if embracing them, and remained fixed in this position the entire time as the flames burned him until he finally fell forward in death.
Fr. Calvez lasted longest of the three, and remained standing, leaning on his stake even after he had died.
Their charred bodies were intentionally left lying in the field as a warning to all, with guards posted to make sure that people could not steal remains (some managed to take some anyway).
The second mass execution in 1623
Three weeks later, on December 25 (one source says it was December 29), a group of 37 prisoners including the wives and children of the first group of martyrs were led out from the same prison to this hill. Also in this group were the man and woman who proclaimed their faith on this very hill three weeks earlier.
Thirteen people in this group were not even Kirishitans but were apparently associated with them in some way. It was a crime to help Kirishitans or harbor them or even rent rooms to them.
There were around 18 children, including some who were so young that they probably did not appreciate the gravity of the situation, and happily went along with their mothers, clutching their toys, a sight which moved many of the onlookers to tears. Some of these children were beheaded, others were slashed from head to navel, or sawn or even torn in pieces by the executioners as their mothers watched. Later their heads were hung from their dead mothers' hands.
The method of killing this time varied. Eleven of the adults were then tied to crosses and run through with spears, and six others were burned at the stake. The man who had previously declared his faith at the first executions was named Francis Kahyoe. Now as the flames rose about him, Francis preached boldly to the crowd about faith in Christ as the only way of salvation.
At the top of that hill, a large stone, a pillar and a plaque on a smaller rock are the only reminders of these dark and evil events. The sign says that Kirishitans were executed by order of Tokugawa Iemitsu, and gives the names of the men who were leaders in the first executions on December 4, which I have mentioned above.
It also mentions that more Kirishitans were executed here on December 30, 1638. I don't know if this is a reference to the second mass execution I mention above (with different dates) or a different one. Most likely they continued to use this hill for occasional executions once it had been set aside for that purpose, since it would be difficult to use it for anything else. Like practically every other place of execution in Tokyo, this site eventually became a public park.
These two mass executions were the beginning of a wave of persecution under Tokugawa Iemitsu. Over the next several years, two thousand Kirishitans would be martyred in Edo.
Although these executions took place outside the walls of the city, modern Tokyo has spread far beyond this point since that time. The Tokaido has turned into a busy street choked with cars and buses, and tall buildings erected on landfill completely obscure the view of the sea which is much more distant now.
The closest train stations are Tamachi Station and Mita Station.
Fumi-e and hidden Kirishitans
The persecution of Kirishitans was ruthless. Informers were rewarded, and whenever Kirishitans were discovered, even their neighbors were put to death. This forced the Kirishitan believers to go underground.
As part of its aggressive campaign to find these hidden Kirishitans, the Tokugawa government required all citizens to be registered as members of their local Buddhist temple.
They also held public rituals on a regular basis where everyone was ordered to trample on fumi-e which were Christian images usually made of bronze depicting Christ or Mary.
This system was introduced in 1629 and continued until Februay 12, 1858.
Anyone who refused to step on the fumi-e was put to death.
Many Kirishitans went bravely to their deaths this way, preferring martyrdom over the shame of abandoning their faith.
However, some Kirishitans complied and trampled the images while secretly holding onto the faith they had publicly renounced.
The rite of contrition took on a new prominence among secret Kirishitans as a way of dealing with the guilt.
These photos show several Fumi-e which were in a special exhibition at the Tokyo National Museum. The faces on most of these are worn smooth from being tramped on by many feet.
Locking down the entire nation
In the late 1630s Tokugawa Iemitsu instituted a number of laws which isolated Japan from the world. This isolation was known as sakoku (locked nation) and was possible because Japan is an island nation surrounded entirely by sea.
During this period no foreigner was allowed to enter Japan and no Japanese was allowed to leave on penalty of death.
This effectively wiped out foreign missionary activity in Japan, and any Japanese who had become Christians during their time in a foreign country could not return to Japan.
Japan became a locked and isolated nation and would remain this way for many years. However, there were still some attempts by missionaries to secretly enter Japan.
Fr. Peter Kasui Kibe was a Japanese Kirishitan seminarian who had been expelled from Japan in 1614. During his years outside of Japan he made his way to Rome, walking much of the way! He made a stop at the Holy Land, becoming the first Japanese ever to enter Jerusalem. He then went on to Rome where he was further trained, and was ordained a Jesuit priest in 1620.
He returned to Japan knowing he would most likely be martyred there. He landed in Kagoshima, and managed to make his way to the Tohoku region in northeast Japan where he worked with the Kirishitans there.
On March 17, 1639 he was captured in Tohoku along with two other Jesuit priests, Giovanni Battista Porro and Martinho Shikimi, and two Franciscan Friars.
The two Franciscans were burned at the stake in Shinagawa,
These new prisoners were such a big catch that even the Shogun, Tokugawa Iemitsu himself was present to observe some of the questioning sessions. A special inquisitor called Chuan was brought in to pursuade the three Jesuits to apostatize.
Chuan was none other than Christovao Ferreira, the former Jesuit priest who had apostatized six years prior in 1633 while in the pit. Now he was working for the Japanese government and living in his own home in Nagasaki. He had been forced to take a Japanese wife, the widow of an executed Chinese merchant, and go by a Japanese name, Sawano Chuan.
This interrogation failed to produce results, and apparently Peter Kibe used the occasion to encourage Ferreira to return to the faith. So Iemitsu took charge and had his specialist Inoue Masashige interrogate the three Jesuits with the goal of getting them to apostatize. This dragged on for ten more days. When it did not succeed, Inoue ordered them to be taken to the pit.
The torture was very effective, and the two companions renounced their faith even as Peter Kibe continued to encourage them to resist. The two were apparently released from torture, but what became of them is not known.
Peter Kibe, however, remained steadfast in his faith and continued to endure the torture until the guards finally got angry and killed him. Some accounts say he was run through with a spear, some say he was killed by applying red hot steel to his body, and yet others say he was disembowelled.
The Tokugawa government recognized the possibility of more missionaries infiltrating Japan at various remote locations, so a central compound was built in Edo where captured missionaries could be brought in from all parts of the country.
The compound was called Koishikawa-Rogoku (Koishikawa Prison) and was at that time in an isolated area in Edo.
The place is better known today as Kirishitan Yashiki (translated into English as Christian Compound or Christian Mansion) and is located in what is now a neighborhood near Myogadani Station.
Well, technically near the station; as is the case with many old neighborhoods in Tokyo, these streets are like a maze, and sometimes you have to walk away from your destination for a short distance in order to arrive there!
This was once a large compound on a hill, surrounded by a wall and owned by none other than Grand Inquisitor Inoue Masashige, who had his own villa there in the south west corner. It was described as being about the same size as Dejima in Nagasaki by someone who was familiar with both places.
Inside this area, a separate walled-in prison compound was built in the north part in 1646 for interrogating Kirishitans, and many were executed there.
I went to this area and wandered around the neighborhood where Kirishitan Yashiki once existed, and found that not a trace remains of the former compound.
There is a street on a steep incline with a tunnel at the bottom (runs under the Marunouchi train/subway line) which is identified on the maps as Kirishitan-zaka (Christian Slope) but there are no signs or markers on the street itself.
During the Edo era this street was inside the compound and ran from the gate at the bottom of the hill (corresponding to the entrance of the current tunnel) to the residence of Inoue Masashige which was located in the area directly behind me as I took this photograph. The entire road was inside the walls of the compound and served as the only road leading in. At that time it was lined with trees and had guarded gates at both the lower and upper ends.
The first missionaries in Kirishitan Yashiki
Kirishitans could be imprisoned and executed in this compound, and it also served as a place to house foreign missionaries who had apostatized.
Among its first occupants were four Italian Jesuits Giuseppe Chiara, Pedro Marquez, Alfonso Arroyo and Francisco Cassola who had infiltrated Japan on a mission to find Christovao Ferreira and convince him to return to the faith.
They landed on the island of Oshima and wore Japanese clothes in hopes of going undetected. However, the locals noticed that their facial features were not Japanese, and reported them to the authorities. They were arrested in 1643 and taken to Hakata on the south island of Kyushu. Then they were moved to Nagasaki where Marquez was subject to water torture, There were several types of water torture in use including forcing the victim to swallow great amounts of water with a funnel and then beating his belly with bamboo rods.
Once again Christovao Ferreira was brought up from Nagasaki to be the interpreter for these proceedings. This was ironic considering the sole reason they came to Japan was to find him. The four were then taken to the prison in Kodenmacho and condemned to the pit where they all renounced their faith under torture.
They were then allowed to live in Japan under confinement, and given Japanese names. Giuseppe Chiara's last name was changed to Okamoto, and he was given a Japanese wife.
They were later moved to the newly built Kirishitan Yashiki to live out their days in solitude. Apparently they were the first missionaries to live there. Nothing more is known of the fate of three of the men, but we know that Chiara remained at the Kirishitan Yashiki until his death forty years later in 1685. Before he died, he stated that he was still a Christian.
The main character Sebastiao Rodrigues in the Novel Silence by Shusaku Endo was based on Giuseppe Chiara. In the novel Rodrigues comes to Japan in search of Christovao Ferreira. The book has also been made into a Japanese movie in 1971, and more recently in 2016 directed by Martin Scorsese. The Scorsese movie is well worth seeing. Although it is based on a fictional work, it is faithful to historical details, including replicas of some of the fumi-e shown in the above photos.
The last missionary in Kirishitan Yahsiki
The last missionary to live at the Kirishitan Yashiki was Sicilian Jesuit priest, Fr. Giovanni Battista Sidotti, who has also been called the "last missionary" to Japan.
Since Japan was officially closed to the world, and it was illegal for missionaries to enter, Sidotti had to gain special permission from Pope Clement XI to go to Japan. He arrived dressed in native Japanese costume at Yakushima Island in Kagoshima, but was immediately spotted and arrested on October 11, 1708 and whisked to Nagasaki. Then he was taken to the Kirishitan Yashiki which had been standing for 62 years in Edo by this time. His arrest was so quick, that he was not able to send any message back to Europe, and it appeared as if he had vanished into thin air.
Nearly two centuries would pass before anybody in Europe learned of what had happened to Sidotti. In 1882 a three-volume study was published in Japan called Seiyo Kibun (record of things heard from the West). These books described the western world, other continents, the Catholic faith, and a contained a record of many conversations the author had with Giovanni Battista Sidotti! Although these books were written in 1714, the inclusion of banned religious content kept them from being published until after the ban was lifted in the late 1800s. However, they were widely circulated in manuscript form until then.
The author of these books was Japanese government official and Confucian scholar Arai Hakuseki who was also an advisor to the Shogun at the time, Tokugawa Ienobu. Arai Hakuseki had interrogated Sidotti and came to have great respect for him, and Sidotti respected Arai as well. They subsequently had many conversations in which Sidotti passed on much valuable information about the western world. Sidotti also insisted that the Japanese government had been misinformed about the western missionaries and that they were not trying to open the way for foreign armies to invade.
Arai Hakuseki advised the Tokugawa government to no longer torture or kill foreign missionaries as had been the usual treatment in the past, but to simply deport or imprison them, reserving execution as a last resort for extreme cases.
Since he was isolated from the outside world, he did not have any further opportunities to evangelize, and was thus spared further punishment -- until he tried to convince the elderly couple (identified by their names Chosuke and Haru) who were in charge of the residence that they should return to the Christian faith which they themselves had abandoned some time earlier.
He succeeded and even went as far as baptising them, which resulted in his being moved to an underground cell despite a petition from Arai Hakuseki to show lenience. Giovanni Battista Sidotti remained in this state and died of starvation on November 27, 1714 at the age of 46.
The Kirishitan Yashiki burned down seven years later.
Giovanni Battista Sidotti had brought with him from Europe a painting of the Virgin Mary, which is now occasionally on display at the Tokyo National Museum in Ueno. To the right is a photograph of that painting.
It is similar to several paintings in Europe entitled "Our Lady of Sorrows" or "Our Lady of the Finger" because one finger is conspicuously visible.
In Japanese it is called oyayubi no seibozo which could be translated, "image of the Holy Mother of the thumb."
It has been erroneously translated elsewhere on the web as "thumb-sized image of Virgin Mary" but I have seen this painting with my own eyes several times,
This painting which depicts a sorrowful Mary with tears on her cheek is a fitting memorial to such a tragic part of Japan's history.
The death of Giovanni Battista Sidotti at the Kirishitan Yashiki brought down the curtain on an era of missionary activity which had begun with Francis Xavier 165 years before.
With the remaining Kirishitan faithful going underground, and no more foreign missionaries arriving in Japan, a period of silence ensued which lasted until the 19th century.
There is an old memorial in this area not far from Kirishitan-zaka. It has a pillar on the right side an old stone marker in the center with faint writing inscribed on it, and over the stone marker is a signboard erected by the local government with information which I have already written here. It mentions Inoue Masahige as well as Giuseppe Chiara and Giovanni Battista Sidotti, and says that the place burned down in 1724. There also a few other small stone memorials on the left.
The old stone marker in the center is unreadable because it is so old and worn. I crouched in front of it for a while trying to figure out how I might be able to read it. Use a bright lamp? Come back with paper and make a rubbing, perhaps?
At that moment a man walked by and stopped to see what I was doing.
I greeted him, and we got into a conversation about the memorial and the stone with the faint script, and he went over to a mailbox which was on the wall behind the memorial to the left and pulled out a plastic folder full of papers (it only looked like a mailbox; it was actually a storage box, and you can see it behind the tree in the photo).
Apparently somebody had already invested the time and energy to figure out what was engraved on the stone, and had printed up copies for visitors. The man gave me a copy which I scanned for this article.
It basically gives the same information I have covered here (except in Japanese, of course).
The remains Giovanni Battista Sidotti discovered
Tokyo continues to change at an incredible pace, and no neighborhood is exempt, not even the old neighborhood which stands on the site of the old Kirishitan Yashiki. When it was announced that a new condominum complex would be built here, the neighbors protested and put up signs demanding the halt of construction plans. The majority of residents are not Christians, but did not want any further "desecration" of this historically significant area.
The protests went unheeded, and the construction work began. As they were digging the land that would become a parking lot, human remains were discovered in April 2014. Objects and earthenware discovered at the site indicate that the remains were from the time period when Sidotti was imprisoned at the Kirishitan Yashiki. An investigation ensued, and two years later it was announced that the DNA from the skeleton was that of Giovanni Battista Sidotti.
The remains of Giovanni Battista Sidotti - Copyright Bunkyo Ward (BUNKYO WARD/AFP)
The DNA is apparently of an Italian man who was over 170 cm tall. According to old records, Sidotti was from 175 cm to 178 cm tall (the height of the average Japanese man at the time was around 156 cm).
As was the case with the excavated Christian remains near Tokyo Station described above, this body was buried, not according to the Japanese custom, but laid out horizontally in a casket according to Christian practice.
The only other Italian males known to have come to the Kirishitan Yashiki were the four missionaries mentioned above: Giuseppe Chiara, Pedro Marquez, Alfonso Arroyo and Francisco Cassola. The fate of three of the men is unknown, but we know that Chiara remained at the Kirishitan Yashiki until he died at the age of 84, and his body was cremated. This skeleton was that of someone closer to Sidotti's age when he died at the age of 46.
Based on the skull and recorded descriptions of Sidotti, the National Museum of Nature and Science in Tokyo proceeded to create a replica of his head, and put it on display.
Two Japanese skeletons, male and female, from the same time period were also discovered nearby. They are most likely the old couple whom Sidotti baptized.
So the period of missionary activity which began with Francis Xavier's arrival in Kagoshima in 1549 came to an end with the death of Giovanni Battista Sidotti 165 years later in Edo (Tokyo) in 1714.
Reopening the nation
Japan continued in its locked and isolated state (sakoku) for nearly a century and a half after the death of Giovanni Battista Sidotti. All contact with western nations was prohibited with the exception of an offshore Dutch factory at Dejima in Nagasaki. Attempts by various nations to establish trade relations with Japan were repeatedly repelled -- sometimes with force.
On July 8, 1853, four United States Navy warships (the famous Black Ships) under the command of Commodore Matthew Perry arrived at Uraga harbor near the mouth of Tokyo Bay with a letter from the President of the United States Millard Fillmore requesting a trade agreement between Japan and the U.S.A.
These ships were huge, black and ominous, with clouds of coal smoke billowing into the air, unlike Japanese sailing vessels.
The Tokugawa government refused to allow Perry's ships to sail further into the harbor which lead to Edo, and surrounded him with Japanese boats. Perry responded by shelling a few buildings on the harbor which caused great explosions and much destruction.
Perry said he would return later for a reply, and sailed on to China.
After he left, the Japanese built fortifications in Tokyo Bay as a defense against a future American attack.
But when Commodore Perry returned to Japan seven months later, he had twice as many ships with him. So rather than try to engage him in battle, the Tokugawa government signed a treaty with the United States granting all their demands.
Other western nations quickly followed in the wake, gaining their own trade agreements with Japan.
This led to the end of sakoku and opened the way for foreigners -- including Christians -- to once again enter Japan. It also sparked a civil war in Japan leading to the downfall of the Tokugawa government and the restoration of the Japanese imperial system with Emperor Meiji as the supreme ruler of Japan.
Incidentally, the area in Tokyo Bay called Odaiba where the fortifications were built to repel the black ships has been turned into a shopping and entertainment complex and prominently features a replica of the Statue of Liberty near the beach.
Discovery of Kirishitan descendants
Although Japan was finally open to the world, the Japanese government made it clear that Christianity was still illegal in Japan, and that Christian worship activities must be restricted to foreign residents only.
Three centuries earlier, the city of Nagasaki in Kyushu had been the hub of Christianity. At one point the percentage of Christians among the residents of Nagasaki had actually reached 100 percent, and it was called the Rome of Japan. When Japan turned on Christianity, Nagasaki became famous for its persecution of Christians, particularly the crucifixion of 26 martyrs in 1597.
After Japan allowed foreign Christians to return to Japan, Oura Church was built in Nagasaki. One of the priests in charge was Fr. Bernard Petitjean.
Even though the priests had left Japan some 200 years earlier, many Kirishitans in hiding continued to worship and pass the faith down from one generation to the next. The faith became a family tradition, and some beliefs and practices of these Kirishitans had morphed into a mixture of Christianity and local religions over the years without teachers or Bibles to guide and correct them.
The Kirishitans also waited and prayed for the return of the priests, whom they would recognize based on three conditions: they would have a devotion to Mary, they would be celibate, and they would be faithful to the Pope.
One of them asked Fr. Petijean what was the name of the "Great Priest who was the Grand Head of the Kingdom of Rome" to which Fr. Petijean answered that it was Pope Pius IX, and that the pope would be happy to hear of their interest. Then they asked him if he had any children, and he replied that his children were these believers and their brethren, and that he must remain unmarried all his life. Hearing this, the small group bowed low and cried out their thanks to God.
As more foreign Christians came to Japan and built churches complete with ordained clergy, many Kirishitans sought to make contact with them and worship with them secretly.
Many visiting Christians were overjoyed to make the acquaintance of Japanese believers, and no doubt assisted them in various ways, and apparently gave them presents such as crosses, medals and rosaries.
Unfortunately this led to a new wave of persecutions as Christianity was still banned, and even possessing such items was illegal.
Thousands of Japanese Kirishitans were arrested, and their possessions seized. Then they were then exiled to different parts of Japan where their lives were ruined. The western nations condemned this persecution and pressured Japan to be tolerant of Christianity.
Finally on February 24, 1873, the signboards which had been posted throughout Japan declaring Christianity illegal were taken down, which implied Government tolerance of Christian evangelization in Japan.
One of the original signboards, now on display at Honjo Catholic Church in Tokyo
It turns out that there were around 50,000 Kirishitans in existence at this time, and roughly half of them were open to instruction and correction so they could join the Catholic Church of their ancestors. What a joyful occasion that must have been for them. Many men from the Kirishitan community went on to become Catholic priests.
"The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the Church."
The years between 1549 and 1650 are called the "Christian Century in Japan." It is said that around 6.3 percent of the Japanese population was Christian during that time and the Church continued to grow at an amazing rate until it was stopped by force.
During the years from the ban on Christianity in 1612 until the time the ban was lifted in 1873, some 50,000 Kirishitans had been executed.
Today the Christians in Japan make up less than one percent of the population.
The Church in Japan now has the freedom to grow from that seed planted by the martyrs without fear of persecution. And yet she has not been able to flourish and grow as she did before those lost centuries.
I pray that the Church in Japan will rebuild on her glorious old foundation stones in the power of the Holy Spirit and with one voice proclaim the good news of Jesus Christ to every person in this nation -- and all of Asia -- and exceed the hopes and expectations of those honored martyrs who gave everything for the Kingdom of God.
As a Protestant Evangelical Christian living in Japan, I was accustomed to hearing the stories of various Protestant denominations which typically began with missionaries who came in response to General MacArthur's call, or perhaps as early as the Meji era nearly 150 years ago.
I came here as an Episcopalian missionary proud of the long history of the Episcopal Church in Japan which could be traced all the way back to its missionaries who arrived here in 1859.
So I'm sure my jaw dropped when I walked into a Catholic church in Japan and read about their history which began with the arrival of Francis Xavier 1549! Suddenly my interest in Japanese history, culture, art and Christianity all came together!
I am now a member of the Catholic Church in Japan, and I hope this article will reflect some of my joy and excitement -- and gratitude for finally discovering this amazing treasure.
Here is a list of some names mentioned above in their Japanese form. You will need to make sure your browser's encoding is set to Japanese (Shift_JIS) in order to see the Japanese characters. Or you can simply view a screen shot of the list here.
Kirishitan: 吉利支丹 切支丹
Shangchuan Island: 上川島
Cosme De Torres: コスメ・デ・トーレス
Brother Juan Fernandez: フアン・フェルナンデス
Alexander Valignano: アレッサンドロ・ヴァリニャーノ
Geronimo de Jesus Castro: ヘロニモ・デ・ヘスス・カストロ
Church of Queen Holy Mary of the Rosary: ロザリオの元后聖マリア聖堂
Luis Sotelo: ルイス・ソテロ
Jisshi Park: 十思公園
Diego de San Francisco: ディエゴ･デ･サン･フランシスコ
Kato Samanosuke Yoshiaki: 加藤 左馬助 嘉明
Inoue Chikugo-no-kami Masashige: 井上筑後守政重
"the pit" : 穴吊り
Fuda No Tsuji: 札の辻
Jerome de Angelis: ジェロニモ・デ・アンジェリス
Francis Galvez: フランシスコ・ガルベス
Simon Enpo： シモン遠甫
John Hara Mondo: ジョアン原主水
Peter Kasui Kibe：ペトロ・カスイ岐部
Giovanni Battista Porro：ジョアン・バプチスタ・ポルロ
Martinho Shikimi: マルティノ シキミ?
Christovao Ferreira: クリストファン・フェレイラ
Sawano Chuan: 沢野 忠庵
Kirishitan Yashiki: 切支丹屋敷
Pedro Marquez: ペドロ・マルケス
Alfonso Arroyo: アルフォンソ・アロヨ
Francisco Cassola: フランシスコ・カッソーラ
Sebastiao Rodrigues: セバスチャン・ロドリゴ
Giovanni Battista Sidotti: ジョヴァンニ・バッティスタ・シドッティ
oyayubi no seibozo: 親指の聖母像
Bernard Petitjean: ベルナール・プティジャン
For further reading
There seem to be very few English language books on Kirishitan history. Most of my information came from library books in Japanese. Here are the few English language books that are out there:Japan's martyr church by Sister Mary Bernard, 1923
In Search of Japan's Hidden Christians by John Dougill
Christianity in Early Modern Japan: Kirishitan Belief and Practice by Ikuo Higashibaba
Silence novel by Shusaku Endo
Kirish'tan: Heaven's Samurai: A novel of old Japan by Luke O'Hara
The Twenty-six Martyrs Museum in Nagasaki
Kirish'tan.com Web site of Luke O'Hara
Kirish'tan Martyrs Blog Blog of Luke O'Hara
Kirishitan History table A compilation of dates and events for my own quick reference. Maybe others will find it useful as well.